
Park Hyatt New York
Best for contemporary, spacious rooms, an on-site full-service spa (Spa Nalai), and a dedicated indoor saltwater lap pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Park Hyatt New York is a contemporary five-star hotel on West 57th Street with large rooms, Spa Nalai, and a 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool — a good read for travelers who want modern, quiet luxury and spa facilities. The St. Regis New York is a historic Fifth Avenue grand-luxury hotel known for its legacy butler service and classic décor — ideal for guests who prefer traditional, formal luxury and a landmark Midtown address.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for contemporary, spacious rooms, an on-site full-service spa (Spa Nalai), and a dedicated indoor saltwater lap pool.

Best for Fifth Avenue address, historic grand interiors, and butler service built into many room types.
When Park Hyatt New York wins: choose Park Hyatt if you want larger-than-typical Manhattan rooms and suites, an on-site full-service spa (Spa Nalai) and a staffed 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool with hydrotherapy facilities.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose The St. Regis for a formal Fifth Avenue landmark experience, a legacy of personalized butler service across many room types, and classic prewar-style luxury close to Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue shopping.
Bottom line: both are top-tier Midtown Manhattan options. Pick Park Hyatt for modern calm, wellness, and larger contemporary rooms; pick The St. Regis for historic Fifth Avenue refinement and traditional service touches like butler service.
| Category | Park Hyatt New York | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modern, residential-style contemporary luxury with curated art | Historic, formal Fifth Avenue grand-luxury with traditional service |
| Location | 153 West 57th Street — across from Carnegie Hall, one block from Central Park | Two East 55th St — steps from 5th Avenue and minutes from Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms & suites) | 210 guest rooms, including 92 suites | 238 air-conditioned guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome (children accommodated); standard check-in 4:00 PM | All ages welcome (not adults-only); check-in policy requires ID and may require 21+ for payment authorizations |
| Pools | 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool (25th floor) with lifeguard, hot tub, steam room | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Living Room Restaurant & Bar (Contemporary American) plus 24-hour in-room dining | 2 restaurants listed and a bar/lounge; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Spa Nalai on 25th floor (hydrotherapy, hammam, two treatment suites) | Not published |
| Signature service | Contemporary personalized service, concierge, and large in-room art collection | Butler service included with many room and suite categories |
| Meeting & event space | About 9,000 sq ft of meeting space including the Onyx Room and BEVY | Conference space: 3,944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family notes | Complimentary Wi-Fi; pool access with key; pets allowed with fee | Complimentary Wi-Fi; multilingual staff; wheelchair-accessible facilities listed |
Park Hyatt sits at 153 West 57th Street, opposite Carnegie Hall and a block from Central Park.
Choose Park Hyatt for immediate access to Carnegie Hall, Central Park views, and the One57/’billionaires’ row’ address.
The St. Regis New York is on Two East 55th St, immediately adjacent to Fifth Avenue shopping and close to Rockefeller Center.
The St. Regis is the pick if you want a classic Fifth Avenue base for shopping and Midtown attractions.
Park Hyatt's 210 rooms — including 92 suites — emphasize large layouts and contemporary finishes.
Park Hyatt suits travelers who prioritize larger, modern rooms and residential-style suites.
The St. Regis offers classic room and suite categories (238 guestrooms) with many listings noting butler service.
The St. Regis is for travelers who want traditional luxury rooms and the extra touch of butler service.
Park Hyatt's on-site restaurant is The Living Room Restaurant & Bar, serving Contemporary American cuisine.
Park Hyatt focuses on a single, chef-driven restaurant and convenient in-room dining.
The St. Regis lists two restaurants and one bar/lounge; room service is available during limited hours.
The St. Regis provides multiple in-house dining outlets and a more traditional hotel dining setup.
Park Hyatt has a 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool on the 25th floor with underwater speakers and a lifeguard.
Park Hyatt is the clear choice if an on-site pool and extensive wellness facilities matter.
The supplier listing for The St. Regis does not publish an on-site pool.
St. Regis emphasizes classic hotel amenities and services; a pool is not published in the supplier listing.
Park Hyatt emphasizes wellness with Spa Nalai and a 24-hour fitness center next to the pool.
Park Hyatt combines a formal spa program with fitness and convenient nightlife access for theater and dining.
The St. Regis lists concierge services, a hair salon, and a 24-hour fitness facility, and its location places it close to Midtown evening attractions.
Choose The St. Regis for a classic Midtown evening experience supported by full concierge and salon services.

Park Hyatt — Spa Nalai plus a staffed 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool and hydrotherapy facilities.

The St. Regis — many room and suite types explicitly include Butler Service.

Park Hyatt — larger-than-typical Manhattan rooms and a high proportion of suites (92 of 210).

The St. Regis — located on East 55th St steps from Fifth Avenue shopping and Rockefeller Center.
Park Hyatt — Spa Nalai is a full-service spa with hydrotherapy, a hammam and signature KOS PARIS treatments; St. Regis' supplier listing does not publish a full spa.
The St. Regis frequently includes Butler Service in many room and suite types; Park Hyatt does not list butler service as a standard feature.
Park Hyatt has a published 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool; an on-site pool is not published in The St. Regis supplier listing.
The St. Regis is steps from Fifth Avenue; Park Hyatt is a short walk (roughly a few blocks) from Fifth Avenue shopping.
Explore how Park Hyatt New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·