
Park Hyatt New York
Best for travelers who want larger-than-average Manhattan rooms, a serious lap pool and a quieter, gallery-like hotel across from Carnegie Hall.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Park Hyatt New York is a five-star Midtown property on West 57th Street across from Carnegie Hall that suits travelers who want large rooms, an on-site saltwater lap pool and a quiet, gallery-like feel. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a five-star high-rise at Columbus Circle for guests who prioritize skyline and Central Park views, a prominent urban spa, and direct access to the Time Warner Center area.
Updated · about 0.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want larger-than-average Manhattan rooms, a serious lap pool and a quieter, gallery-like hotel across from Carnegie Hall.

Best for guests who prioritize skyline and Central Park vistas, a high-profile spa program, and immediate access to Columbus Circle shopping and dining.
When Park Hyatt New York wins: choose Park Hyatt if you want larger standard rooms and suites, direct proximity to Carnegie Hall and a 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool plus Spa Nalai on the same floor — good for fitness- and wellness-focused stays.
When Mandarin Oriental wins: pick Mandarin Oriental for dramatic full- or partial-Central Park and skyline views, a signature MO Spa experience and the convenience of the Time Warner Center/Columbus Circle address for transit and shopping.
Bottom line: both are five-star Midtown hotels within easy walking distance of each other and Central Park; Park Hyatt leans toward roomy, residential luxury with an emphasis on pool and art, while Mandarin Oriental emphasizes view-driven rooms, an iconic spa and a Columbus Circle setting.
| Category | Park Hyatt New York | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Residential, art-forward luxury with quiet, refined public spaces | High-rise, view-focused luxury with a lively Time Warner Center setting |
| Location | Across from Carnegie Hall on West 57th St; 1 block from Central Park | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th St; steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 210 guestrooms, including 92 suites | 244 guestrooms |
| Building & floors | Occupies the lower 25 floors of One57 | High-rise hotel within Time Warner Center (high floors for views) |
| Pools | 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool on the 25th floor with lifeguard | Indoor pool (1) listed in supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | The Living Room Restaurant & Bar (Contemporary American) + in-room dining | MO Lounge / 1 restaurant and 2 bars listed in amenities |
| Spa & wellness | Spa Nalai on 25th floor (KOS PARIS partnership, eucalyptus steam room, hammam) | Full-service MO Spa with massages, facials and treatment rooms |
| Known for | Large rooms and suites for Manhattan; art collection; pool/hydrotherapy facilities | Panoramic skyline and Central Park views; high-profile spa and Columbus Circle access |
| Family & age policy | All ages welcome; children accommodated | |
| Transit access | Close to 57th St–7th Ave subway; easy walking to Midtown attractions | Immediate access to Columbus Circle transit links and nearby attractions |
Park Hyatt sits at 153 West 57th Street directly across Carnegie Hall and one block from Central Park.
Park Hyatt places you nearest Carnegie Hall and a slightly quieter stretch of Midtown.
Mandarin Oriental occupies 80 Columbus Circle at West 60th Street, adjacent to Columbus Circle and the Time Warner Center.
Mandarin Oriental is ideal if you want immediate access to Columbus Circle and sweeping city/park vistas.
Park Hyatt emphasizes larger rooms and a high suite count in Manhattan.
Choose Park Hyatt for larger standard rooms and many suite options.
Mandarin Oriental's rooms highlight skyline and Central Park sightlines.
Mandarin Oriental is a strong pick if panoramic views factor heavily in your room choice.
Park Hyatt offers a single on-site restaurant and 24-hour room service.
Expect a focused, chef-driven dining program plus easy access to Midtown restaurants.
Mandarin Oriental lists one restaurant and two bars in its supplier amenities.
Mandarin Oriental balances an on-site lounge with the dining options and stores of Time Warner Center nearby.
Park Hyatt's standout non-room feature is the 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool on the 25th floor.
If an in-hotel lap pool is a priority, Park Hyatt is a clear choice.
Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool among its amenities.
Mandarin Oriental offers an indoor pool, though Park Hyatt's pool is more specifically documented and highlighted.
Park Hyatt centers wellness around Spa Nalai and a 24-hour fitness center.
Park Hyatt is strong on integrated spa, hair services and fitness facilities.
Mandarin Oriental's wellness strengths are its full-service MO Spa and health club.
Mandarin Oriental combines a recognized spa brand with convenient lounge/bar options and fitness facilities.

Park Hyatt — a 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool with underwater speakers and a lifeguard on duty.

Mandarin Oriental — high-floor rooms with strong Manhattan and Central Park sightlines from Columbus Circle.

Park Hyatt — 210 rooms with many generously sized suites and family suite options.

Mandarin Oriental — located at Columbus Circle with direct access to shopping, transit and nearby dining.
Both are within a short walk to Central Park, but Mandarin Oriental sits at Columbus Circle while Park Hyatt is one block from the southern end of the park across from Carnegie Hall.
Park Hyatt's 65-foot indoor saltwater lap pool is specifically documented; Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool but the supplier listing does not give the same level of detail.
Yes — both properties accept guests of all ages and list childcare/babysitting (surcharge) among available services; supplier listings note up to two children 12 and under stay free at Mandarin Oriental when using existing bedding.
Both have full-service spas: Park Hyatt features Spa Nalai (KOS PARIS partnership) and Mandarin Oriental operates the MO Spa. Choose based on whether you prefer Spa Nalai's advertised hydrotherapy/hammam focus or MO Spa's signature Mandarin programs.
Explore how Park Hyatt New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·